streitwert-abmahnung-filesharing

Teuer: Übersicht über Filesharing-Streitwerte Deutscher Gerichte

Post vom Rechtsanwalt bekommen und Abmahnung erhalten? Rufen Sie an, wir beraten Sie sofort!

 

Aktalisiert am 04.03.2013 !

 

Aus unserer Beratungspraxis: Streitwerte der Gerichte bei Filesharing

Im Rahmen eines einer Abmahnung wegen Filesharing oder einer Urheberrechtsverletzung werden von den Rechteinhabern (Abmahner) regelmäßig drei Ansprüche gegen den abgemahnten geltend gemacht:

1. Unterlassungsanspruch
2. Aufwendungsersatzanspruch (Rechtsanwalts- und Ermittlungskosten)
3. Schadenersatzanspruch

Hinsichtlich der beiden letztgenannten Zahlungsansprüche wird dann gewöhnlich ein Vergleichsbetrag angeboten, welcher innerhalb einer gesetzten Frist anzuweisen ist; für den Fall der Nichtzahlung wird hingegen eine gerichtliche Geltendmachung wesentlich höherer Kosten angedroht. Wir haben hier eine Übersicht zusammengestellt, aus der sich die Schadenersatzansprüche ergeben, die Deutsche Gerichte bisher ausgeurteilt haben.

Da bei der Kalkulation des angeblichen Gesamtschadens die Rechtsanwaltskosten einen erheblichen Teil ausmachen und sich diese nach dem Streitwert bemessen, haben wir einmal den aktuellen Stand der Rechtsprechung zusammengestellt, aus der sich ergibt, wie hoch die Gerichte den Streitwert bemessen( Stand 03/2013). Aus dem Streitwert errechnen sich Anwaltskosten und Gerichtskosten sowie das finanzielle Prozessrisiko. Auf eine Abmahnung nicht zu reagieren, kann somit teuer werden:

Musik:

Streitwert          Bemerkung                                                      Gericht +

in EUR                                                                        Aktenzeichen der Entscheidung

 

1.200,00           1 Musikalbum                                                  AG Wildeshausen

                                                                                              (4 C 497/09)

2.000,00           1 aktuelles Musikalbum                                     AG Elmshorn

                        (12 Titel)                                                          (49 C 57/10)

2.500,00           1 Musiktitel                                                      AG Düsseldorf

                                                                                              (57 C 15740/09)

2.500,00           1 Musiktitel                                                      OLG Düsseldorf

                                                                                              (I-20 W 68/11)

3.000,00           1 aktuelles Musikalbum                                     AG Aachen

                        (12 Titel)                                                          (115 C 77/10)

3.000,00           1 Musiktitel                                                      OLG Köln

                                                                                              (6 W 234/11)

5.000,00           1 Musikalbum                                                  LG Magdeburg

                                                                                              (2 S 226/10)

6.000,00           1 Musiktitel                                                      LG Hamburg

                                                                                              (308 O 139/06)

                                                                                              (308 O 220/06)

10.000,00         1 Musiktitel                                                      LG Köln

                                                                                              (28 O 480/06)

                                                                                             

LG Düsseldorf

                                                                                              (12 O 594/07)

                                                                                             

LG Frankfurt am Main

                                                                                              (2/3 O 19/07)

                                                                                              (2-06 S 3/12)

                                                                                              AG Frankfurt am Main

                                                                                              (29 C 549/08)

                                                                                              LG Leipzig

                                                                                              (5 O 4020/11)

10.000,00         1 Musikalbum                                                  KG Berlin

                                                                                              (24 W 72/10)

                                                                                              OLG Köln

                                                                                              (6 W 44/11)

15.000,00         2 Musiktitel                                                      OLG Köln

                                                                                              (6 W 139/10)

15.000,00         4 Musiktitel                                                      LG Hamburg

                                                                                               (308 O 220/06)

15.000,00         10 Musiktitel                                                    OLG Hamburg

                                                                                              (5 W 173/06)

19.500,00         6 Musiktitel                                                      LG Hamburg

                                                                                              (308 O 326/07)

20.000,00         2 Musiktitel                                                      LG Hamburg

                                                                                              (308 O 76/07)

                                                                                              LG Köln

                                                                                              (28 O 596/09)

20.000,00         1 Musikalbum                                                  LG Düsseldorf

                                                                                              (12 O 134/09)

25.000,00         1 Musikalbum                                                  LG Hamburg

                                                                                              (308 O 439/09)

30.000,00         3 Musiktitel                                                      LG Köln

                                                                                              (28 O 150/06)

40.000,00         4 Musiktitel                                                      LG Köln

                                                                                              (28 O 384/06)

50.000,00         1 Musikalbum   (weder besonders aktuell,         LG Köln

                        noch besonders erfolgreich)                             (28 O 596/09)

                                                                                              Amtsgericht Hamburg

                                                                                              (36A C 172/10)

50.000,00         5 Musiktitel                                                      LG Düsseldorf

                                                                                              (12 O 73/11)

50.000,00         11 Musiktitel                                                    AG Hamburg

                                                                                              (36a C 479/11)

70.000,00         7 Musiktitel                                                      LG Köln

                                                                                              (28 O 10/07)

                                                                                              (28 O 266/06)

100.000,00        1 Musikalbum                                                  LG Köln

                                                                                              (28 O 421/09)

120.000,00        294 Musiktitel                                                   LG Köln

                                                                                              (28 O 515/10)                                                  

160.000,00        543 Musiktitel                                                   LG Köln

                                                                                              (28 O 241/09)

200.000,00        265 Musiktitel                                                   LG Düsseldorf

                                                                                              (12 O 177/10)

200.000,00        964 Musiktitel                                                   OLG Köln

                                                                                               (6 U 101/09)

200.000,00        1.026 Musiktitel                                    LG Köln

                                                                                              (28 O 237/09)

200.000,00        1.147 Musiktitel                                    LG Köln

                                                                                              (28 O 716/10)

400.000,00        3.749 Musiktitel                                    LG Köln

                                                                                              (28 O 202/10)

Film:

Streitwert          Bemerkung                                                      Gericht +

in EUR                                                                        Aktenzeichen der Entscheidung

1.200,00           1 Film                                                              AG Halle

                                                                                              (95 C 3258/09)

10.000,00         1 Film                                                              LG Hamburg

                                                                                              (308 O 321/10)

                                                                                              (310 O 433/10)

                                                                                              LG München I

                                                                                              (21 O 1099/10)

                                                                                              (21 O 1100/10)

                                                                                              (21 O 1101/10)

                                                                                              LG Magdeburg

                                                                                              (7 O 1337/10)

                                                                                              LG Berlin

                                                                                              (16 O 433/10)

15.000,00         1 Film                                                              AG Hamburg   

                                                                                              (35a C 154/11)

                                                                                              OLG Köln

                                                                                              (6 W 278/11)

20.000,00         1 Film                                                              LG Berlin

                                                                                              (16 O 139/10)

                                                                                              (16 O 143/10)

                                                                                              LG Lübeck

                                                                                              (2 O 227/09)

30.000,00         1 Film                                                              LG München I

                                                                                              (7 O 4716/10)

                                                                                              (21 O 4329/10)

                                                                                              (37 O 1103/10)

                                                                                              LG Hamburg

                                                                                              (308 O 345/09)

                                                                                              LG Düsseldorf

                                                                                              (12 O 97/10)

                                                                                              OLG Köln

                                                                                              (6 W 44/10)

50.000,00         1 Film                                                              LG Köln

                                                                                  (28 O 509/10)

                                                                                              (28 O 763/10)

100.000,00        1 Film                                                              LG Köln

                                                                                              (28 O 771/09)

Software:

Streitwert          Bemerkung                                                      Gericht +

in EUR                                                                        Aktenzeichen der Entscheidung

10.000,00         1 PC-Spiel                                                       LG Köln

                                                                                               (28 O 508/10)

                                                                                              LG Frankenthal

                                                                                              (6 O 156/08)

15.000,00         1 PC-Spiel                                                       LG Saarbrücken

                                                                                              (12 O 98/07)

15.000,00         1 PC-Spiel                                                       OLG Köln

                                                                                              (6 W 165/11)

15.000,00         1 PC-Programm                                               OLG Köln

                        (Multimedia-Lexikon)                                         (6 W 20/09)

20.000,00         1 PC-Spiel                                                       LG Hamburg

                                                                                              (308 O 246/10)

20.000,00         1 PC-Programm                                               AG Magdeburg

                        (Diagnose-Software Kfz)                                  (140 C 2640/09 (140))

20.000,00         1 PC-Programm                                               OLG Köln

                        (Diagnose-Software Kfz)                                  (6 U 31/10)

30.000,00         1 PC-Programm                                               AG Magdeburg

                        (Multimedia-Lexikon)                                         (140 C  2323/09 (140))

Die aufgezeigte Spannbreite der möglichen Streitwerte macht deutlich, dass es immer sinnvoll ist, die benannten Streitwerte kritisch zu hinterfragen und anhand der aktuellen Rechtsprechung zu überprüfen.

https://ssl-vg03.met.vgwort.de/na/7c945b693798428bbc94eda046327116